But Why Bump Off Barnaby?, MADS at Mere Lecture Hall

SEVERAL hours on I am still not quite sure whether the Mere Amateur Dramatic Society production of But Why Bump off Barnaby? was a brilliant satire on am-drams or a disastrous example of all those things that can, legendarily, go wrong with a non-professional production.

Whatever the answer, this really could become a cult, if only it was running long enough.

Rick Abbot, the pen-name of American writer Jack Sharkey, published more than 80 plays, as well as working as a joke editor for Playboy and editing the company magazine for Allstate Insurance. The lunatic murder mystery But Why Bump Off Barnaby? was first published in 1981 and is set in the 1950s.

Its premise is that, at one of those familiar family gatherings in crumbling old mansions, one of the guests, Barnaby Folcey, has a perfect motive for wanting to murder all the others. But no-one, absolutely no-one, has a motive to kill this inoffensive poor relation who is not even part of the tontine, the group of people who will inherit a hidden fortune.

So when the lights flicker and die, who is left with a dagger in his back ? …. none other than Barnaby.

The dramatis personae includes Orion Leduc, owner of the creaking pile that is Marlgate Manor, a woman who wants to be Mrs Orion Leduc, a film-star relative and a man she picked up in a bar, an old retainer and a very deaf and entitled (in the real meaning of the word) old aunt. Then there is Dora Dunstock (which looks like a programme spelling mistake for Dumbstock, but isn’t), a niece who now lives in America. Orion has hired a butler and a house maid to cater for the dinner and the all-important meeting that is scheduled to follow it.

There are moments of inspiration in here, and genuinely funny ideas, all of which could work on a versatile set operated by highly-skilled technicians, who also have control of the lighting and sound effects.

The first night at Mere was disturbed by the last minute illness of the man due to play Orion, the central role. Les Mainwaring, a MADS stalwart, was too ill to go on, and so director Tim Trenchard took over, knowing the plot and the moves but not the words, so reading from the script. A few other actors were not too familiar with the script either, and took prompts for which they politely thanked the prompter, Sandie Ankers.

Juliet Booth and Penny Allen, both regulars on the Lecture Hall stage, demonstrated their perfect comedy timing as Dora and the deaf Lady Barbara. Sue Tabor captured the prissy pedanticism of Mis Barnsdale. Jennifer Trenchard brought a nice modernity to Magnolia the house-maid and John Smillie’s butler Medkins had just the right pompous touch.

It is good to see an unfamiliar murder mystery, and this one might work under different circumstances, but the timing required, from the cast and technical crew, like that of those Shows That Go Wrong, is meticulously rehearsed and very, VERY difficult to pull off.

GP-W

Posted in Reviews on .